Federalism: If you
learn only one thing about the American system of government in this class,
then learn this: the U.S. has a federal system of government. Unlike unified
or centralized systems (such as monarchies), the U.S. system divides sovereignty
(power or authority to govern) among three levels of government: local,
state, and national. Or, more accurately, ultimate authority resides in
the people (“We the People...”; “...of the people, by the people, for the
people”) and the operation of government is divided among the three levels.
Under the Constitution, each level has sovereignty within in its sphere.
Their experience during the late colonial period and the Revolutionary
War taught Americans to distrust centralized or distant authority. Instead,
they demanded representative government (republican government).
And many preferred that most of the power be kept close at hand—on the
state level. As the U.S. grew, however, tensions arose between a group
known as the Anti-Federalists later the Democratic-Republicans (followers
of Thomas Jefferson) and the Federalists (followers of Alexander Hamilton).
The two groups fundamentally disagreed over what the U.S. should become.
Jeffersonians wanted America to be made up of small republics where a homogeneous
(not diverse) population of small farmers (yeomen) toiled close to the
earth and governed themselves. Hamiltonians, on the other hand, envisioned
an expansive American industrial empire governed by an educated and wealthy
elite. Under this view, power had to be more centralized so that government
could protect business and America could compete with the Great European
powers, notably Britain. As with all things American, neither side won
completely. Instead, what we had was a compromise that satisfied neither
side fully. American history, therefore, has seen an uneasy working out
of conflict over who is in charge (central or local), whether it is the
conflicts over tariff and banking policy in the early national and Jacksonian
periods, or the Civil War, or the New Deal, or the Civil Rights Movement.
English Economics and Exploration, 1485-1600
![]() |
King Henry VIII: English monarch (1509-1547) notable for having six wives and for treating them brutally when none could give him a surviving son; more notable for breaking away from the Roman Catholic Church in order to divorce his first wife and creating the Church of England (Anglican Church) – the break would lead to more than 100 years of conflict between Catholics and Anglicans over control of Great Britain |
![]() |
Queen Elizabeth I: English monarch (1558-1603), known as “The Virgin Queen” because she never married; a capable and strong-willed leader who benefited from a growing English commercial economy and an increasingly powerful navy; chartered the first permanent English colonies in the New World |
Spanish Armada, 1588: Naval fleet sent by King Philip II to invade England; its defeat at the hands of English sailors, such as Francis Drake, marked a turning point of imperial relations in Europe (and the New World); Spain would never again be as strong a nation as it was before the defeat of the Armada
Enclosure Movement: In
the sixteenth century, England underwent a significant internal
reorganization. As wool prices rose, landowners began fencing
land (enclosing the land) to make more room for grazing sheep.
Englishmen greatly increased the production of wool, channeling it
through the Antwerp Wool Market.
Huge profits were made, bringing more people into the market and
increasing production even more. By mid-century England produced more
wool than Europe could consume. The price crashed in 1551. The collapse
of the market led English policymakers to search for ways to avoid such
economic disaster in the future. They sought new markets as outlets of
wool and cloth. And to get more capital into the economy, individual
investors pooled their money in proto-corporations, or joint-stock
companies.
The Enclosure Movement forced poor tenants off
the large estates that had been their home for centuries. Although
population posed no problem in England, the visible presence of
vagabonds and unemployed disturbed may powerful Englishmen. Many
believed that England was over-populated and looked for some outlet.
European rivals, Spain and France, had created
colonies in the Caribbean and Florida causing further concern in
England.
The three elements (markets, surplus
population, and international rivalry) created a nexus that provided
the impulse for colonization.
John Cabot:
Although England was but a rather negligible world power in the late
fifteenth century, it mustered enough resources to begin its own age of
exploration. In 1496, King Henry VII commissioned the Genoese sea
captain John Cabot, “to seeke out, discover, and find whatsoever
isles, countreys, regions, or provinces of the heathen and infidels
whatsover they be” and to look for a shorter sea route to “Cathay”
(China). Cabot did not find the Northwest Passage, but he did discover
the Grand Banks, a fishing region at the edge of the continental shelf
and claimed them for England. Cabot was lost at sea on his second
voyage. His son, Sebastian, retraced Cabot’s route and reached as far
as the entrance into Hudson’s Bay
|
|
English Motives for Colonizing: The key architects of this movement for colonization were two cousins who became prominent in the court of Queen Elizabeth, Walter Raleigh and Richard Hakluyt. Raleigh provided the money; Hakluyt provided the reasoning. Hakluyt’s Discourse of Western Planting,
(1584) offers the clearest expression of why England should create
colonies in the New World. The Oxford clergyman wrote it to convince
Queen Elizabeth I to grant permission to colonize America. The book
suggests ways that colonies could benefit England: (1) to extend “the
reformed religion”; (2) to expand trade; (3) to provide England with
needed resources and markets; (4) to enlarge the Queen’s revenues and
navy; (5) to discover a Northwest Passage to Asia; and (6) to provide
an outlet for the growing English population.
| Sir Walter Raleigh: Raleigh succeeded in winning a charter
to organize a private
expedition to the area around Albemarle Sound at Roanoke Island in
1585. Raleigh’s 108-man team clashed with local Indians, but they
remained through the winter. Hardship plagued the settlement, however,
and in the late spring the group packed up and returned to England with
Francis Drake when he happened by.
Croatoan, The
Lost Colony: A
ship had already been sent to relieve the first, but its eighteen men
were killed in an Indian attack. A second expedition landed off
Hatarask Island in July 1587. Led by Governor John White, its 117 men,
women, and children resettled on Roanoke Island. White left the
settlers, including his granddaughter, Virginia Dare (the first English
child born in the New World), and returned to England for supplies.
Before leaving, White carved the letters C.R.O. into a tree and told
the men to carve a cross over them as a distress signal should they run
into trouble before he returned. He did not return for three years
because of the conflict with Spain and the Spanish Armada. |
joint-stock company: Corporations created by investors who buy shares of the company in hope of getting rich off of the profits of the company
joint-stock colony: a colony controlled by a joint-stock company; shareholders determined the governance of the settlement; Virginia and Massachusetts Bay are joint-stock colonies at founding
proprietary colony: a colony controlled and owned by an individual or family: the later colonies, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, etc., all start out as proprietary colonies
Mercantilism: Economic system based on trade where a nation tries to export more than it imports. European nations establish empires to produce the goods needed to make them “self-sufficient.” As the system progresses, the mother country tries to control all elements of trade among its colonies.
The American Colonies, 1600-1793
The Chesapeake
| Queen Elizabeth’s death in 1603 did not interrupt Britain’s pursuit of global power. King James I, in 1606, granted charter to a joint-stock company headed by Richard Hakluyt. The Virginia Company of London, as it was known, divided the British claims in North America with a rival company, the Virginia Company of Plymouth. The original charters had no western boundaries; hence in theory, they ran from the Atlantic to the Pacific. The London Company was made up of merchants and gentry from the west of England and from London, itself. | ||
| Jamestown: | On December 20, 1606, three ships, the Susan Constant (120 tons), the Godspeed (40 tons), and the Discovery (20 tons) left London with 144 passengers, under the command of Captain Christopher Newport. The ships briefly laid over at the Canary Islands and the Bahamas, before arriving in Virginia at Chesapeake Bay on April 26th with 104 survivors. | |
![]() |
Following
the orders of the London Company, and after facing a brief conflict
with the local Indians, the Powhatan, the ships landed up the
newly-named James River and encamped at what became Jamestown on May
13, 1607. Of the 104 survivors, 39 had noble titles and 36 more were
described as gentlemen. The others were attendants, soldiers, and
artisans skilled at metalwork—that is to say, they were goldsmiths and
jewelers. Among the soldiers was a boorish troublemaker of immense ego, Captain John Smith. Smith’s mouth more than once got him into trouble with his commanders, as near the Canaries he was accused of trying to foment a mutiny and so was locked up for the rest of the voyage. When the settlers unsealed their orders, however, they found that Smith was named to the Council of the Colony and put in command of the day-to-day running of the settlement. |
|
| From the outset, the settlement was in trouble. Located on the site of an abandoned Indian village and in the Powhatan hunting grounds, it continually faced Indian attack. Many of the settlers refused to work. Instead they searched for gold and left the chore of building shelter to the soldiers. Instead of gathering or hunting for food, many chose to steal it from the Indians, causing no small amount of hostility. The Indians, meanwhile, raided Jamestown to steal weapons and gunpowder. Smith tried to force all to work and, failing that, traded for Indian maize. The English also gave Chief Powhatan a formal coronation and made him an ally of King James. This briefly improved relations with the Indians, but did little to guarantee the success of the colony, neither did the arrival of some women to the community. Conditions hit bottom during the winter of 1609-1610, after Smith returned to England as a result of an illness. That winter was known as “The Starving Time”: Crop yields were miniscule because of a drought, but there was still game in the woods and fish in the river. Despite that, however, starvation reduced the settlement’s population from nearly 500 down to 54 by the time a ship finally arrived with fresh provisions and new settlers in May 1610. Shockingly, settlers had resorted to cannibalism to survive. They dug up graves to eat the remains. Equally shocking, the new Assistant Governor recorded the settlers’ activities as he sailed in. They were not out foraging for food in the spring forests. They were bowling in the street! Obviously, this settlement needed a reworking. In June 1610, Governor Lord De la Warr restored order through a new code, the Lawes Divine, Moral, and Martiall. All settlers were required to work in work gangs under military discipline. The day was divided by drumbeats: 6 a.m. until 10 a.m. they worked in the fields. During the heat of the day, they ate, did household chores, and rested. They were back in the fields again from 2 p.m. ‘til 4 p.m. If they still did not work hard then they would be punished. Punishments were also meted out for crimes, such as: rape, adultery, theft, lying, sacrilege, blasphemy, killing a domestic animal, weeding a garden, taking of a crop, and private trade. Anyone who ran away from the settlement and was caught was executed. The new rules helped save the colony, but they still could not feed themselves. The colony had still not found its purpose and the London Company’s investors were beginning to wonder whether it had been worth it, particularly after a new round of conflict with the Powhatan emerged about 1611. |
John Rolfe: Rolfe
arrived in Jamestown in May 1610 aboard Gates’ ship. Rolfe had brought
with him to Virginia some Spanish tobacco plantings, hoping
successfully to cultivate them. By 1612, he gave his friends a small
sampling of his produce to see if it suited their tastes. While not of
the quality of Spanish tobacco at the time, it was still palatable
enough for larger-scale cultivation. By 1617, Virginia shipped 20,000
pounds of tobacco (at 3 shillings per pound) to England and the crop
became so profitable that if became known as “brown gold.” Rolfe also brought peace with the Indians. In 1614, the First Powhatan War ended when Rolfe married the daughter of Chief Powhatan, Pocahontas.
In 1616, Rolfe, Pocahontas, and their son traveled to England and
Pocahontas met the King. Tragically, just before they set sail to
return to the New World, the 22-year-old Pocahontas died, likely of
pneumonia. She is buried in a churchyard at Gravesend.
Virginia, 1610s to 1620: With the colony saved, under new Governor Edwin Sandys, the London Company created a new policy for land distribution and to entice more settlers. The headright system
promised that every new company shareholder who settled in Virginia
would get 50 acres of land for himself and 50 acres for each “family
member” he brought over, including servants. Further to entice
settlement, the company a new constitution for the colony, granting
settlers the “Rights of Englishmen.”
In July 1619, Virginia created the House of Burgesses,
the first legislative assembly in America. Its twenty-two members
represented their local settlements and governed along with a Governor
and executive council.
Two
other events in 1619 further expanded the colony: (1) more women
arrived as the company sponsored the sale of women for wives – 90 women
were bought for the princely sum of 125 pounds of tobacco – creating a
better gender balance in the colony; (2) the first Africans arrived –
they came on a Dutch trade ship, but were indentured servants, not
slaves.
An indenture
is a contract. So, in return for the master’s paying their passage to
the New World, an indentured servant contracts to work for a specific
term, usually seven years. During that time the servant has no rights
to property. Upon completion of the term, the servant is free to do
whatever he or she wishes and under Virginia law would receive a
headright of 50 acres.
The
policy created by the London Company to entice immigration to Virginia:
each settler would receive 50 acres of land and an additional 50 acres
for each family member – this helped to increase the population of the
colony and make it more stable. The shift from a commodity-based
company to a realtor changed the London Company’s relationship with the
colony. The company’s new goal was to get as many people to Virginia as
possible. It cared less about the condition of the settlers when they
got there and so the condition of the colony suffered. Making matters
worse, an Indian war arose.
Opechancanough’s Wars: Powhatan’s brother, Opechancanough,
seems never to have accepted the settlers or his brother’s peace. Upon
his brother’s death, in March 1622, he led raids on the settlement that
turned into nearly two years of warfare and killed 347 settlers,
including John Rolfe. The turmoil finally caused King James to appoint
a Royal Commission to investigate the Company. It found that between
1607 and 1622 more than 14,000 people had emigrated to Virginia, but in
1624 only 1,132 of them still lived there. The investigation forced
James I to revoke the Company’s charter and make Virginia a Royal Colony.
Under the king’s authority for most of the remainder of the
1620s, Virginia stabilized and slowly began to prosper. In 1642, Governor William Berkeley
arrived in Virginia to begin thirty-four years of stable governance.
But colonizing was still no easy task. Conditions had sufficiently
improved to make slavery a more viable economic choice. Relations with
the Indians, however, remained difficult. In 1644, an elderly
Opechancanough led a second raid on the colony. It, too, killed several
hundred settlers, but this time, the colonists were strong enough to
retaliate with great force. The raid was put down and hostilities with
the local Indians ended.
| Bacon's Rebellion (1676):
Tobacco production increased through the 1630s. But, ironically, it was
so profitable that so many settlers began planting tobacco that for
much of the period after 1650 it glutted the market, causing the price
to fall, and pushing marginal farmers into severe debt. As the
population of poor grew and as the colony spread deeper into the
interior, above the falls at what would become Richmond and toward the
Blue Ridge and up the Potomac, it became harder to govern the colony.
Adding to public displeasure was the fact that Berkeley’s government
had become a clique of family members and business relations. The
colonial treasurer was a Berkeley cousin, as was the Secretary of State. The discontent reached a head in 1675. Settlers on the frontier believed the government was not looking after their interests. In particular, they thought it was not protecting them from Indian attack – as settlement moved west it came into lands of different Indian tribes, notably the Susquehanna. A minor squabble between settlers and Indians along the Potomac turned ugly and left nearly twenty-five Indians dead. The Indians retaliated by attacking settlers along the frontier and the James River. The overseer of an up-river planter named Nathaniel Bacon was killed in a raid. Berkeley proposed a series of forts be built along the frontier, but the assembly believed it would be too expensive and besides what the settlers really wanted was to get rid of the Indians and take their land. Tensions grew. In May 1676, Nathaniel Bacon led a group of vigilantes against the Indians, despite Berkeley’s prohibition. Then Bacon and his men, a collection of landless servants, small farmers, and slaves, turned around and went on a rampage down river, ultimately torching Jamestown itself. By October, the rebellion was over, however, and Bacon was dead, from malaria. Order was restored and Berkeley had twenty-three of the rebels executed. When news of the rebellion reached England, Berkeley was recalled and a new regime was put in place in Virginia, one that more clearly protected the interests of common Virginians. A peace treaty was made with the Indians who were given reservations of protected land, leaving the rest for development by colonials. By 1677, the difficult infancy of Virginia ended. Now a toddler, the colony would prosper. |
![]() |
Beyond
staple crop agriculture, the plantation’s distinguishing mark was its
social order, conceding nearly everything to the slaveowner. In theory,
the planters’ rule was complete. From his Great House, he looked out
upon trades-shops, barns, sheds, cabins, and other outbuildings that
were known as “dependencies.” The plantation would also include all the
various trades’ shops that would be necessary
to run a large farm: blacksmith, tanner, cooper, carpenter, etc. As
slavery
replaced indentured servitude, the trades were often taken over by the
slaves (dislocating white workers) and the gentry increased their
dominion
over their land and region (making workers white and black more
dependent
on them).
But the masters’ authority radiated beyond
the estate to statehouses, courtrooms, counting houses, churches,
colleges, taverns, and the like.
New England
Puritanism: The reformed
church created out of the English Reformation. Its main beliefs include
a desire to “purify” the practices of the Christian church by eliminating
many of the rites of the Roman Catholic church; belief in the idea of predestination;
salvation by grace alone; local (congregational) selection of clergy; and
personal reading of the Holy Bible; and election, as in those elected
by God to be saved. Structurally, Puritans advanced the idea of a bottom-up
organization, reversing the structure of the Catholic Church. This placed
the congregation in charge of church government and the individual in charge
of his own salvation.
During the reign of
Elizabeth I, Puritans were not totally free to worship as they chose,
but neither were they persecuted. King James I was less hospitable,
however, and the Puritans split into two groups: the Puritans (who
wanted to stay in England and work within the system to reform it) and
the Separatists (who
said enough is enough, England is lost beyond redemption; let’s find
somewhere else to live). So they left the town of Scrooby in England
and moved to the town of Leyden in the Netherlands in 1609. After years
in Holland, the Scrooby Separatists
feared the moral decay of their community amid the permissive Dutch
culture. In 1619, they contracted with the London Company to settle in
Virginia and the crown ensured that they could practice their religion
freely there. With financial help from a group of merchant adventurers,
they set up their voyage.
|
|
Plymouth
Colony: In July 1620, 35 of the 238 members of the Leyden congregation, led by William Bradford, sailed aboard the Speedwell to Southampton to meet more Separatists and the 180-ton Mayflower.
After two false starts, including a forced docking at Plymouth after
the Speedwell turned out to be too leaky, the 102 saints and strangers
set sail for Virginia. The Separatists called themselves the Saints – as in visible saints, those elected to heaven; the others, a majority of the passengers, they called strangers
and included Anglicans and at least one Roman Catholic, Miles Standish.
Two months later, 103 landed along Cape Cod – two babies were born and
one youth died en route – some five hundred miles off course. Since
they could not be governed under the London Company’s charter, being so
far north, the men aboard agreed to write up a new contract for the
settlement. Called the “Mayflower
Compact”,
it represented the first example of self-government in the New World.
The settlers agreed to create a system of laws, to elect leaders, and
to obey those laws and leaders. A month later, on December 20th, after several reconnaissance missions, the settlers chose an abandoned Wampanoag village as the place to build their Plimoth Plantation. Out of food and exhausted, they soon discovered that they had made the right choice; for in the abandoned village they found buried a large store of maize, enough, when replenished with fish and game, to see the settlement through the winter. In March of 1621 a truly strange coincidence further proved to the pilgrims that they were destined to come to Plymouth. A Mohegan Indian named Samoset arrived at the plantation to inform them that Massasoit, the Wampanoag chief, intended to visit. Another Indian, named Tisquantum, arrived with Samoset. Remarkably, Tisquantum began talking to the pilgrims in English and told them that he had seen London. Calling him Squanto, the pilgrims learned that he had been captured by European fishermen and sold into slavery to Spain. He had been in the West Indies and the Canaries and had escaped his Spanish captors and fled to England. While in England he learned English and then he arranged to board an English ship and sail back to America; just in time for him to be here when the pilgrims arrived. Squanto taught the pilgrims how to grow maize, fertilizing the ground with rotting fish. By the autumn, the pilgrims harvested their first crop and gave thanks to God for the bounty. Through the 1620s, Plymouth grew into several communities, spreading from Cape Cod to the Kennebec River in what is now Maine. |
Massachusetts Bay Colony: 1n 1623, with Plymouth established and growing, a group of settlers traveled north to Cape Ann looking for fishing grounds. English migrants from the town of Gloucester joined them and established the settlement of Gloucester.
Within three years, a number of fishing villages dotted Cape Ann. In
1628, in search of more capital for better equipment and to generate
more settlement, the sponsors of these settlements formed a joint-stock
company, the Massachusetts Bay Company.
They petitioned the king for a charter to lands between the
southernmost point of the Charles River and the Merrimac River. The
charter granted the “freemen” of the company the right to select all
officers, admit newcomers to freemanship, to make laws and administer
those laws through a general court. The company then sent Governor John
Endecott and sixty Puritan followers to establish the town of Salem in 1629.
The company’s primary goal was profit and
economic opportunity, but conditions for the Puritans in England had
deteriorated under Charles I,
James I brother and an ardent Catholic. He had run into conflict with
the Presbyterians in his native Scotland and he had no intention of
tolerating the English Calvinists.
During the 1630s, some 80,000 people left England for the New World. It was known as the Great Migration. Of those, about 20,000 came to Massachusetts Bay.
In 1629, a group of well-placed and wealthy Puritan landholders drew up the Cambridge Agreement
in which they pledged to go to the New World with their families and
their fortunes. Although partly a business venture, the colony would
be, as John Winthrop called it, a “Wilderness Zion,” a place of religious refuge for persecuted Puritans.
In March 1630, led by Governor Winthrop, 400
Puritans left for the New World. They landed at Salem, June 12, 1630.
600 more Puritan settlers soon followed, ultimately to create a new
community at the mouth of the Charles River to establish the
Massachusetts Bay Colony. While aboard the Arbella, Winthrop set out his plan for the colony in a sermon, titled A
Model Of Christian Charity
based on the line from the Gospel of Matthew 5:14 “You are the
light of the world. A city set on a hill cannot be hid.”
Fundamental Orders of Connecticut: Connecticut grew out of western extensions of the Massachusetts Bay Colony along the Connecticut River. In 1636, Thomas Hooker led three congregations to the region where they founded the towns of Wethersfield and Hartford. John Winthrop, Jr. led a group that planted itself at Saybrook. The settlements were originally governed from the Massachusetts General Court, but as they grew they chose to avoid the arduous travel to Boston and established their own legislature. In 1637, the settlers created Connecticut. In 1639, they wrote the “Fundamental Orders of Connecticut.” Although similar to the Massachusetts Bay charter, in Connecticut a man did not have to be a church member to participate in government. Thus the “Orders” represent a democratizing of colonial government.

Roger Williams:
Williams was an ardent Separatist, but he came from England to Boston,
not Plymouth. He would likely not have been happy anywhere, but he was
especially unhappy in Boston. He believed that the Puritans’ earlier
unwillingness to leave the Church of England contaminated him and would
have nothing to do with them. So Williams made his way up to Salem to
try out their congregation, but he found them just as unsatisfactory.
Then he moved on to Plymouth to see if the Separatists themselves would
meet his criteria. They did not. At its heart, Williams’ problem with
the colonies was that he believed that there should be complete
separation of church and state and that no one could be coerced into
belief. He held that the “perfect church” could have no contact with
the unregenerate. This eventually led him to believe that no true
church was even possible on Earth.
Back in Salem, Williams began to agitate
against the government, claiming that magistrates had no authority in
religious matters. As his criticisms became less restrained and more
dangerous to the stability of the colony, Williams was brought before
magistracy councils to renounce his opinions. He refused, and talk
began about deporting him to England. Before that happened, however,
Governor Winthrop allowed him to solve the problem himself. In the
spring of 1636, he left Massachusetts and established the settlement on
Narragansett Bay. He called it the Providence Plantation, and it was the first permanent settlement in Rhode Island.
At
Providence, Williams fulfilled all of his goals: (1) he bought the land
from the Indians, something he had always criticized the settlers of
Massachusetts Bay for not doing; (2) he permitted believers of any
Faith and non-believers, as well, to live there; (3) government service
required no religious test—there was complete separation of church and
state.
Anne Hutchinson:
In 1637, the 46 year-old midwife, pregnant with her 16th child, got
into trouble in the Massachusetts Bay Colony by preaching the “covenant
of grace.” That meant that one was freed from moral law by one’s faith
and by God’s grace. She also contended that individuals could be in
direct contact with God and receive His direct inspiration. This was
heresy. Puritans argued that being among God’s elect proved that you
had to show your election through works; and that it was a sin of pride
to believe that God would have direct contact with any human.
Hutchinson was forced out of Newtown (later Cambridge) in 1638. She
first sought refuge in Narragansett country with a group of followers
under William Coddington who eventually founded Portsmouth, New
Hampshire. She then found her way to Long Island among the Dutch. In
1643, she was killed in an Indian attack.
She has since become a symbol as a victim of the
religious intolerance of the Puritans. But her life is more complicated
than that. She did not fit in anywhere and may more likely have be
victim of a time that did not respect the opinions of women. Winthrop
called he death, “a special manifestation of divine justice.”
|
Those lands that were developed were parceled out to each man as tiny
house-lots, with additional strips of arable meadow and woodland
scattered around the village. Though property was not divvied up
equally, each family received a share of land or crop in an organized
communal fashion. All lands not distributed were held in common. The
whole community used the “common lands” or “commons”
for grazing cattle or sheep. As population grew, rights of private
ownership and the ability to decide how to use one’s own land expanded.
By the early 1700s, with town lands already distributed, the second or
third generations of Puritans often had to move elsewhere to find
opportunity. Thus, migration within and between colonies was common. New England came to be characterized by family farms on which all toiled. Slaves, composed mostly of Creoles from the West Indies, worked as household servants and field hands. The region’s rocky soil kept farms small, although as the region moved into the eighteenth century, larger landholdings similar to plantations did develop in Rhode Island and along the Connecticut River, where tobacco had taken root. Slavery became increasingly important to these areas, but it was not so important that it kept New Englanders from abolishing it after moral questions were raised during the Revolution. The New England economy eventually developed a powerful landholding, merchant class that traded internationally and dominated American shipping. Before that came about, however, the Puritans tried to create a self-sufficient economy. They hoped not only to produce enough food for the population, but also to establish industry. The manufacture of iron goods and cloth were attempted without much success. The main problem for New Englanders was that they did not have the capital necessary to compete with English industry. And worse than that, the English had no intention of allowing them to compete. The fledgling Saugus Iron Works, the nation’s first industrial “factory” ran for less than five years in the 1650s. Textiles mills met a similar fate. Both were brought down by mercantilism. |
![]() |
Pequot’s War (1634-37): As the Plymouth and Massachusetts Bay colonies grew, they came into conflict with Indians trying to hold on to ancestral lands. Problems began when Narragansett allies to the Dutch were killed as they traveled through Pequot land and then the Dutch retaliated, killing the Pequot chief. After a brief peace, in 1636 the Pequot were implicated in the death of a settler and Massachusetts Bay sends a force of ninety men to destroy the Indian settlement. In retaliation for that, the Pequot attack Saybrook and Wethersfield, Connecticut. The colonials respond with the help of the Narragansett and destroy the Pequot settlement on the Mystic River, killing 700 tribesmen and capturing the rest. In the peace settlement, the Pequot are eliminated as a tribe and distributed among the Mohegan and the Narragansett.
| Named after Chief Metacomet, whom the
English called King Philip, tensions began when Philip’s older brother
Alexander was imprisoned in Boston where he caught a fever and died.
Then an Indian who had converted to Christianity and had testified
against Alexander was murdered. When the English settlers executed
three Wampanoag tribesmen for the murder, Metacomet retaliated by
destroying the town of Swansea, killing eight. Colonial volunteers
formed a brigade to avenge the town. Philip held the upper hand
throughout the spring of 1675 until the third day of a siege at
Brookfield when colonials killed eighty Indians. For more than a year, war raged in Connecticut, Rhode Island, and Massachusetts, colonials answering every Indian assault with an equally vicious attack. In a fierce battle near South Kingston, Rhode Island, the colonials destroyed the Indian settlement and killed more than seven hundred, wounding and leaving for dead another three hundred or so. By late summer 1676, the Wampanoag had had enough. Philip escaped capture and ran away but was found out and killed in a final showdown. After his death, colonials forced the remaining Indians into submission, taking their land. By the time it ended, thirteen colonial towns had been destroyed and at least six hundred settlers had been killed and nearly two thousand wounded. The defeated Indians fared far worse, losing more than one thousand to death and many of the remaining were captured and sold into slavery in the West Indies. |
![]() |
Salem
Witch Trials, (1692): Historical event shrouded in foggy interpretation,
at its heart it involved several young girls, likely influenced by the
stories of a slave named Tituba, accusing people of being witches and of
putting spells on them. As the hysteria grows, the town divides. In the
end, 20 people are put to death for witchcraft and 100 more are imprisoned.
At the peak of the hysteria, the girls confess that they made the whole
thing up.
The Proprietary Colonies
English Civil War: Religious conflict between Catholics and Puritans from 1617-1649 (although it dates back to the 1540s) and becomes particularly fierce in the 1640s, ending with the beheading of King Charles I and a victory by the Puritans; Puritans rule as a Long Parliament under Oliver Cromwell for ten years but monarchy is restored in 1660 in the person of Charles II
proprietary colony: a colony controlled and owned by an individual or family: the later colonies all start out as proprietary colonies: Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, North Carolina, Georgia|
New York:
In 1609, the Dutch East India Company had hired Henry Hudson to discover the “Northwest Passage.” Hudson sailed the coast of North America and located the river that now bears his name. He sailed as far up-river as he could but was stopped by rapids at what is now Albany, New York. Not able to go farther, he met with the local Mohican Indians and negotiated a contract for the Mohicans to provide furs to the Dutch. They sealed the deal with a few kegs of brandy. In 1614, the Dutch established trading posts on Manhattan Island at the mouth of the river and Fort Orange at a site below the rapids. Ten years later, the Dutch West India Co. established a settlement at what is now Governor’s Island. In 1626, Peter Minuit bought Manhattan Island from the Indians and moved the settlement there, calling it New Amsterdam. The colony spread west to the Delaware, east to the Connecticut River, and north to the Mohawk River but remained only thinly populated because its focus was on furs. The company did encourage settlement. It established the patroon system, modeled after the European manorial and the French seigneurial systems. A stockholder governed a patroonship, a large estate on the Hudson River, if he peopled it with 50 adults within four years, and established herds, barns, mills, and any other necessities for farming. The tenants would treat him as “lord of the manor,” paying him rent, using his mill, and submitting to his authority. The patroon system did little to entice settlers, however, because too much open land was available and few Dutchmen wanted to volunteer for serfdom. The English Civil War raged for most of the decade of the 1640s and the Puritans took control of the English government in 1646. In 1649, they executed the king. The beheading ushered in eleven years of Commonwealth. In 1660, the Commonwealth collapsed and the people restored the Stuarts to the thrown. The Restoration of the crown in England, in the person of Charles II, led to the official recognition of Rhode Island and Connecticut. It also led to new expansion into the new world. The Dutch expanded their territories while the British were engaged in Civil War. The British Crown fretted over the Dutch presence dividing the English colonies and Dutch control of the best routes into the interior of North America (the Hudson and Mohawk Rivers). Charles II decided to push the Dutch out. The rivalry resulted in war in 1664 when an English expedition led by Col. Richard Nicolls reached New Amsterdam. Dutch Governor Peter Stuyvesant vowed that the Dutch would fight. But without the supplies, weapons, or the will to withstand the English, the Dutch surrendered without a shot being fired. King Charles granted the lands to his brother James, the Duke of York and the colony became New York. Some of the Dutch returned to Holland, but most of them stayed. Nicolls was made governor. |
![]() |
With so many non-English in the
colony, representative government was slow to evolve. Still,
inhabitants were given certain guarantees: (1) local property holders
could elect a constable and eight overseers to supervise town
government; (2) the towns would be placed under justices of the peace
named by the governor; (3) these justices aid the governor in making
laws; and (4) because of the diverse polity--made up of Frenchmen,
Swedes and Finns, as well as Dutch and English--there was complete
religious toleration. In 1682, a legislature was established and wrote
the Charter of Liberties and Privileges, guaranteeing colonists the “Rights of Englishmen.”
But, in 1685, when James became King James II he turned New York into a
royal colony, the charter was denied and the legislature dissolved.
Taking New Netherland gave England
control of lands between the Hudson River and Delaware Bay. The Duke of
York gave control of these lands to friends John Berkeley and George
Carteret. The land became known as New Jersey. The colonies of East Jersey (Carteret) and West Jersey (Berkeley) became important outlets for surplus populations in New England and New York.
![]() |
William Penn (1644-1718):A
leading Quaker in West Jersey was William Penn. While at Oxford, Penn
converted to Quakerism and in the middle 1670s became interested in
America. With the land west of the Delaware River still unorganized, he
hoped to establish a “Godly experiment” in the New World. He petitioned
for a patent. Penn’s father had loaned the king £16000; so in
1681 Charles II granted Penn a patent to the land. As proprietor, Penn
had the right to name the governor and establish a government. The colony was to be named Pennsylvania, meaning “Penn’s woods.” In 1682, Penn took control of the colony of Delaware when the Duke of York gave it to him. Delaware became a separate entity in 1703. Motives of Quaker migration were economic, moral, and political, but religious freedom predominated. In the 1680s, persecution against Quakers intensified. Charles II dissolved Parliament and began to rule without constitutional restraint. |
| Politically, Penn was closely acquainted
to a group called Whigs, a Parliamentary faction that challenged the
authority of the King’s court. Penn advised Freeholders to guard their
rights as Englishmen. “For the matters of liberty and privilege,” Penn
declared, “I propose that which is extraordinary, and to leave myself
and successors no power of doing mischief, that the will of one man may
not hinder the good of the whole community.” Penn actively recruited settlers from throughout the British Isles and Europe, leading to a great diversity of population. English and Welsh Quakers made the journey, as did members of German dissenting religions such as Mennonite, Amish, Moravian; and Lutheran Rhenish Germans. Later in the century, Scots-Irish immigrants joined the English, Welsh, German, Dutch, Swedish, and Finnish settlers. A significant majority of the settlers who came to Pennsylvania were tradesmen; dominant among the remainder were merchants. |
![]() |
|
Penn’s Prospectus for Merchants, 1683
Your Provincial Settlements both within and without the Town, for Situation and Soil, are without Exception: Your City-Lot is an whole Street, and one side of a Street, from River to River, containing near one hundred Acers, not easily valued; which is besides your four hundred Acers in the City Liberties, part of your twenty thousand Acers in the Countery. Your Tannery hath such plenty of Bark, the Saw-Mill for Timber, the City-Lot for a Dock, [all] to help your People, that by God’s blessing the Affairs of the Society will naturally grow in their Reputation and Profit. I am sure I have not turned my back upon any Offer that tended to its Prosperity: and though I am ill at projects, I have sometimes put in for a Share . . . advance her interest, [particularly in] whatsoever tends to the Promotion of Wine, and to the Manufacture of Linnen in these parts. . . . I shall add no more, but to assure you, that I am heartily inclined to advance your just Interest, and that you will always find me . . . Your Kind Cordial Friend. William Penn |
The last colonies settled in the seventeenth century were the Carolinas. A
proprietorship for the region south Virginia was arranged as early as
1629. At that time, Charles I rewarded Attorney General Robert Heath
with the tract. Heath called it “Carolina”--a Latin form of
Charles--but he did nothing to organize it. Some settlers did venture
into the area around Charleston, but by the time of the Restoration,
the land was under royal control. Some sources trace the name “Carolina” to the early French colonists, naming it for King Charles IX.
In March 1663, wanting to stop Spanish encroachment north, Charles II
gave Carolina to friends, wealthy landholders in other colonies. Many
of the proprietors held land in the islands of the Barbados. Led by
John Colleton, they formed the Corporation of Barbados Adventurers.
Colleton hoped to use it as an outlet for the growing Barbadian
population and to provide the Barbados with food. The company settled
the southern section first. Thus, South Carolina became a “colony of a
colony.”
The Barbadian Adventurers distributed land
along a headright system to recruit settlers. Immigrants were given 100
acres of land to settle. Persons too poor to pay their own way could
come as indentured servants. The wealthier slaveholders who emigrated
from the Barbados received an extra headright for each slave they
brought—20 acres for a male and 10 acres for a female slave.
The “first fleet” of settlers landed in
September 1670, a hundred more in February 1671. About 30 percent
of the population was black—either Creole or African. Charleston
quickly became the most important southern port in the colonies. It had
the finest natural harbor on the Atlantic coast south of Chesapeake Bay.
| The
South Carolina economy was based on staple crop production: rice. The
slaves from West Africa were experienced in the cultivation of rice,
and they employed their expertise to make the proprietors rich. They
were also cattle herders. Thus, South Carolina became a significant
beef producer for the colonies. With a prospering economy based on
slavery, the population of South Carolina swelled. Blacks were even
more perfect inhabitants of South Carolina because they were better
able to withstand the diseases of the semi-tropical climate. The cycle
cell made them less susceptible to malaria. By 1720 (if not a bit
earlier), blacks became a majority in the colony. It was the only
colony ever to have a black majority. |
![]() |
The northern region of Carolina was slower to develop. The
first settlers of the region were Huguenots seeking refuge from Roman
Catholic domination in France in the 1560s. That colony was wiped out
by successive attacks by Indians and by the Spanish. Sir Walter
Raleigh’s failed Roanoke adventure followed in the 1580s.
Under Lord Albemarle,
the region began to be settled in the 1660s. The first settlers were
Virginians dissatisfied with opportunities there. After 1685, it was a
refuge for Huguenots. Louis XIV’s persecution also caused Swiss and
German Protestants to immigrate. Still, it grew slowly because of its
isolation and inadequate harbors. Bath, the colony’s first town, was not founded until 1704.
North Carolina did offer economic opportunity once settlement started
in earnest and by the time of the Revolution its population topped
110,000.
Its staple crop was tobacco, but the colony
became equally important as a supplier of stores to the Royal Navy (naval stores): timber, tar, and turpentine.
The last colony settled was Georgia. In 1733, James Oglethorpe
received a royal charter for King George II to found a colony south of
the Carolinas on land bought from the Creek Indians. The King’s goal
was to have a buffer with Spanish Florida. Oglethorpe a Member of
Parliament in the 1720s had grander plans. He had made prison reform,
particularly prison for debt, a focus of his attention and sought to
provide opportunity and a second chance for debtors in a sort-of penal
colony. This drove Oglethorpe to establish Savannah.
He arranged that slavery would be prohibited in in the colony and
transported mulberry bushes to the settlement to create a silk industry.
Oglethorpe and the first convicts arrived at
the Savannah River in February 1733. The colony remained small,
disorganized, and unprofitable until the Revolutionary Era. The silk
industry failed. The penal system failed. And settlers turned to
African slavery as their labor source, growing rice. Georgia became a
royal colony in 1755. Even after that the colony remained small and
concentrated around Savannah (surrounded by the Creek Confederacy). Not
until the expansion of a cotton industry, especially after the
invention of the cotton gin (1790s), and the Creek ceded more land
(1805) did Georgia truly succeed.
Colonial Development Overview
Albion's Seed: Population Growth to 1760
Interestingly, where the settler was from in England strongly
influenced where he or she ended up in America. As David Hackett
Fischer has written, America grew from Albion’s
Seed. Men (mostly men anyway) from the south of England, from London to
Bristol, tended to settle in the Chesapeake. Families from East Anglia,
the shires of Essex, Suffolk, and Norfolk, as well as working-class
Londoners, tended to settle in New England. Those from the Midlands and
the north of England, as well as Wales, settled the mid-Atlantic
colonies. And Scots and Scots-Irish (those who had first tried their
hand at colonizing Northern Ireland) tended to settle in the
“Backcountry,” the frontier lands of each colony nearing the
Appalachian Mountains.
Because the bulk of the population was comprised of newcomers, the
social structure of the English colonies, at first glance, looked like
that of the mother country. The social hierarchy that symbolized the
class system in England was transplanted with the settlers, as “lesser”
almost always deferred to the “betters.” A free-holder always deferred
to a planter and a servant deferred to a free-holder.
One fundamental difference did exist, however. The colonies were
characterized by social mobility rather than a fixed class system. Many
of the first landowners of Virginia had died or returned to England.
The next wave of settlers was comprised of men of lesser means, having
only one or two servants or no servants at all. They succeeded or
failed by their own labors.
The turmoil evinced by Bacon’s Rebellion or the others of which we
will speak resulted from the fact that those who had made their own
success refused to be governed by cliques or entrenched elites.
Immigration
to America was extremely dangerous and lifespan in the colonies was
very short early on. Diseases, such as diphtheria, small pox, yellow
fever, malaria, and dysentery, ravaged the settlers, particularly in
the Southern colonies, and kept population growth slow; as did the
dearth of women. In 1625, the population of Virginia was about 2000.
During the 1630s it grew slowly, but by the time of Opechancanough’s
Second War in 1644 the population was still only 8,000. Within thirty
years, however, Virginia’s population had quadrupled to about 32,000
and thirty years farther on, it doubled again to about 75,000. New
England’s population grew more rapidly: from one hundred in 1620, to
12,000 in 1640, to more than 100,000 in 1700. And although the Middle
Colonies of Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and New York started later, they
grew even more rapidly, reaching about 70,000 by 1700. Until about
1675, or so, growth came primarily from in-migration. After that it was
caused by a combination of immigration and natural growth.
![]() |
By
the early 1700s, a somewhat more fixed social structure had developed,
particularly in Virginia and South Carolina, at least at the upper end
of society. Success brought more land and more slaves. Large planters
formed a “gentry,” an aristocratic, well-educated, and refined elite
who fancied themselves English country gentlemen. Wealthy merchants in the Delaware Valley—Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and carrying over into Maryland—combined land-holding and business acumen to enter the upper class. But points north and east (except for along the Hudson River where the wealthy old patroons carried over from the Dutch years) tended to be more middle class until later in the century when further urbanization had taken effect. Along the Appalachian Backcountry life remained rustic and brutish for most of the colonial period. It is essential to note in all this, however, that a person could quickly move up or down the social ladder as his fortunes rose or fell in the fluid American economy. |
|
Stage One: Social Simplification: Historical Development – gradually they become more settled - with more population (i.e. density and creolization) and with more economic wherewithal |
![]() |
|
Stage Two: Social Elaboration: Historical Development – with greater population resources and with improved economic prosperity, society becomes more settled and more internally complex |
![]() ![]() |
|
Stage Three: Social Replication: Elites have strong desire to replicate British society in America and disproportionately contribute their will, dominating colony; they take pride in the metropolization, becoming models of the “good” life The replication of English society is not complete nor necessarily harmonious as creolization (frontier influence) alters institutions and norms. Tension exists over social design and which elites will rule. Historical Development – by the 1760s, the disparate colonies converge and out of this convergence comes an American cultural order waiting to be defined by the Revolution and independence |
![]() |
Slavery
![]() |
Triangular Trade: As
the plantation economy expanded, two three-way trade systems among
Africa, Europe, and the Americas developed. In one, sugar - producing
Caribbean islands sent molasses to New England where it was turned into
rum; then the rum along with other goods were shipped to Africa where
they were traded for slaves; slaves then made the middle passage across
the Atlantic to the sugar-producing islands and the rice and tobacco
producing colonies. In the other, raw materials and food stuffs went
from the Americas to Europe; manufactured goods from Europe were sent
to the Americas and Africa; and then European traders shipped African
slaves to the New World. Middle Passage: Horrific trip of slaves across the Atlantic from Africa to the New World. Estimates suggest that 10 million Africans were transported to the New World (about 5% coming to British North America or the U.S.) Slaves were crammed so tightly into ships that as many as 20% died from disease and starvation during passage. Schools of sharks followed ships to feed off of the dead slaves buried at sea |

Colonial Relations with the Mother Country
Navigation Acts: The English believed that the colonies should provide England with raw resources--furs, lumber, and fish--as well as a market for English manufactured goods.
| James II’s agent, Governor-General Edmund Andros,
arrived in Boston in December 1686. Even had Andros not been overly
authoritarian, he would have faced a discontented citizenry; but
Andros’ officiousness and the excesses of King James II back in England
combined to create the short and very unhappy history of the Dominion
of New England. Older, larger, and more independent minded,
Massachusetts bristled at the new regime. Andros tried to appease the
colony by guaranteeing that laws enacted by the General Court and not
in direct violation of new principles would remain in effect, but in
areas of taxation, representation, and religion the citizens found his
authority unacceptable. One of Andros’ first acts was to levy new taxes.
Relative to taxes in England, the taxes were not onerous but the
colonials had always had the right to tax themselves. When citizens
published handbills protesting the measures, Andros appointed a censor
to block any pamphlets on public affairs that the Dominion government
found offensive. Most troubling for citizens of Massachusetts was the
plan to establish the authority of the Church of England.
He turned the South Meeting House into an Anglican church. He required
all marriages to be “solemnized” by an Anglican minister. When a
prominent minister preached against the new regime, he was arrested and
denied a writ of habeas corpus
informing him of the charges. When challenged on it, Andros responded,
“The scabbard of an English redcoat shall quickly signify as much as a
justice of the peace!” |
![]() |
James II, an avowed Roman Catholic, began to exploit his royal prerogatives to enhance Catholic influence in government. “We cannot but heartily wish,” the king declared, “that all the people of our dominions were members of the Catholic Church.”The king’s excesses caused England’s latent political factions to develop into the more clearly defined Court Party (King’s Court; a.k.a Tories) and Country Party (Parliament; a.k.a. Whigs). When James remarried, a French Catholic woman who was “with child,” his opponents in Parliament saw a future of bloody religious conflict. They rebelled, soliciting the aid of the Dutch husband of James’ daughter Mary, William of Orange. Armed with the promise of the kingdom, William and his troops landed to “rescue Protestantism.” Within six weeks, James fled to France and the bloodless Glorious Revolution of 1688 ended. William became King William III and his wife Queen Mary II.

When Andros learned of the overthrow of James II, he had the messenger thrown in jail. But the news could not be contained and neither could the wrath of colonials. Bostonians wrote a declaration of Andros’ “crimes” and arrested him and other of James’ agents. Andros tried to escape, but was shipped back to England for hearings there. The Massachusetts General Court reconvened as the government of the colony and petitioned the new regime for restoration of their charter. King William appointed a governor friendly to the colonials, Sir William Phips, but Massachusetts remained a royal colony.
The Glorious Revolution bred other conflicts in America, as colonials
challenged James’ authority. In Maryland, a long-running tension
between the Protestant majority and the ruling Catholic minority
erupted as the largely-Congregationalist Protestant Association
took advantage of William’s ascension. It petitioned the new king
suggesting that the Calverts were plotting to give the colony to the
French. The crown revoked the family’s charter, establishing Maryland
as a royal colony. The Calverts were restored to power in the colony in
1715, by which time the family had converted to Anglicanism, but the
king had to approve any governmental appointments and all legislation.
When word of the Glorious Revolution reached New York, Andros’
lieutenant, Francis Nicholson, ordered Manhattan’s garrison fortified
with militiamen under the pretext that the French might invade the
colony in retaliation for James’ ouster. Many of the militia believed
that Nicholson really intended to use the military to impose Catholic
rule over them. Jacob Leisler
led a revolt that proclaimed the colony for the new king and queen.
Supporters of King James fled to Albany and held out there until a
French attack actually did occur, the attack that would grow into King
William’s War. In December 1689, King William blessed the rebellion,
telling Leisler to “stay in his post.” Leisler governed Manhattan and
parts of downstate New York for two years until a royal governor
arrived in 1691. While in power, he convened a representative assembly
that reformed many of the most obvious political and economic evils. He
initiated the collection of customs duties and organized a military
expedition against Canada. By May 1691, Leisler’s support had ebbed. He
refused to give up control, but was quickly overwhelmed. He and his
son-in-law were tried and hanged for treason. Among his chief opponents
were members of the Livingston family who would come to govern New York
and represent it at the continental congresses during the revolutionary
era.
Although
wrapped up in larger geo-political and imperial issues, Leisler’s,
Bacon’s, and Culpeper’s Rebellions, and the Protestant Association
exposed a deep rift between those in power and those out of power,
between an economic and/or social ruling elite and the populace. Each
colony had to accommodate the rights and interests of the many as well
as the few if it was going to survive and prosper.
They did not evince a desire to overthrow
British rule, as each of the colonies willingly submitted to the new
regime, indeed when Virginia established the second college in the
colonies (after Harvard, 1636) in 1693, it was named the College of
William and Mary.
The English Enlightenment:
The Glorious Revolution occurred as Europe, and particularly Britain,
was experiencing an important change in world-view. Known as the
“English Enlightenment,” it reflected the advance of the scientific
revolution that had been ongoing for more than a century.
The most important scientist of the revolution was Sir Isaac Newton
(1642-1727). Newton went to Cambridge University, excelling in physics,
theoretical mathematics, and optics. A devout Christian, he was also
interested in metaphysics and alchemy. Newton came up with his basic
theories of physics at the age of 24, but could not prove them. Twenty
years later, he developed theoretical proofs for his “laws of physics.”
Working day and night, seldom stopping to eat the meals brought to him,
breaking away only to teach his classes. A year before the Glorious
Revolution, Newton published Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, or more commonly the Principia. The most important laws included a definition of a law of gravity and his three laws of motion.
The scientific
revolution bred new approaches to other elements of life, including
politics. The most important political thinker of the English
Enlightenment is John Locke
(1632-1704). The eldest son of a respectable Somersetshire Puritan
family, Locke’s formative years were surrounded by religious and
political tension. He was strongly influenced by the events of the
English Civil War and Interregnum. Freedom of thought and to a lesser
degree action became the foundation on which he built his philosophy.
Two works by Locke stand out: An Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690); and Two Treatises of Government (1690).
First, and paramount, in Locke’s view of
political society is the idea that mankind at the beginning of time
were free and endowed with certain natural rights: life, liberty, and property. It was in a complete state of nature,
free from obligation, free to do whatever they chose to do. While this
state of nature had its advantages, it was not satisfactory for the
maintenance of a sustained existence. Nature is dangerous because the
strong can devour the weak. One’s life, liberty, or property were
constantly at risk. Locke’s predecessor, Thomas Hobbes,
described life in a state of nature as “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish,
and short.” To survive, men joined together in the spirit of community
to protect their rights. They left a state of nature and created
government. Man kept his freedoms--the right freely to pursue property,
the right to mobility, and the right to life. But his freedoms were not
absolute. By joining society, man had to conform to the will of that
society’s laws. This is, in a sense, a contract between individual man
and society: a social contract.
To this point, Locke is not radically different from his predecessor
Hobbes. Where the two part company is over what happens if the contract
is broken not by man, but by government. Locke’s answer is that in such
times man has a right to revolt against the government. The revolution is a conservative one, however: to restore the community to the original terms of the contract. Locke’s writing is a justification of the Glorious Revolution of 1688.
Locke’s An Essay Concerning Human Understanding
is an inquiry into “the original, certainty, and extent of human
knowledge.” In other words, Locke wanted to know how men think and how
they come to “know” or “understand” things. It arose out of a debate
between Locke and his friends over the “principles of morality and
revealed religion” as related to questions of faith and reason.
According to Locke, “we are of necessity ignorant, and want knowledge
of all sorts, where we want ideas . . . we are ignorant, and want
rational knowledge, where we want proofs . . . we want probability to
direct our assent in matters where we have neither knowledge of our own
nor testimony of others to bottom our reason upon.” Because we lack
physical certainty in religious questions, there is religious
conflict—one opinion battling another. “For till it be resolved how far
we are guided by reason, and how far by faith,” he argues, “we shall in
vain dispute, and endeavor to convince one another in matters of
religion.” Thus, we have the distinction between what is knowable and what is only suspected or taken on faith.
Part of the appeal of the Puritan faith at its inception was its
resolution of reason and piety. As we can see by Locke’s discussion,
however, that balance was beginning to break down. Locke’s
resolution of the problem, his emphasis on reason over faith, satisfied
many of the more educated in the colonies, such as Jonathan Edwards.
But it left the masses cold; they preferred a more emotional response
to the shifts occurring in society around them. The opposing trends in
religion merged into an often contradictory movement during the 1730s
and 40s—the Great Awakening.
Wars for Empire, 1689-1763:
| European War | Major Participants | Colonial War | Dates | Treaty |
| War of the League of Augsburg | England & Holland vs. France | King William’s War | 1689-1697 |
Treaty of Ryswick
(1697) |
| War of the Spanish Succession |
England, Austria & Holland
vs. France & Spain |
Queen Anne’s War | 1701-1713 |
Treaty of Utrecht
(1713) |
| War of the Austrian Succession |
England & Austria
vs. France & Prussia |
King George’s War | 1744-1748 |
Treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle
(1748) |
| Seven Years’ War |
England & Prussia
vs. France, Spain, Austria, & Russia |
French and Indian War | 1754-1763 |
Treaty of Paris
(1763) |
King William’s War, (1689-1697):
(a.k.a.
War of the League of Augsburg) with England and Holland fighting France.
A tie, the French take English territories of Newfoundland and Hudson Bay,
and England gets Gibraltar at the entrance of the Mediterranean Sea.
Queen Anne’s War, (1701-13): (a.k.a. War of the Spanish Succession) with England, Austria, and Holland fighting France and Prussia. Colonists from Charleston destroy St. Augustine, (now Florida). New Englanders attack Quebec, but fail. England regains Hudson Bay, Acadia, and Newfoundland.
King George’s War, (1744-48): (a.k.a. War of the Austrian Succession) with England and Austrian fighting France and Prussia. As a world war, it is a tie. In North America, England took a major French fort, Louisburg, showing her naval dominance and paving the way for an assault on Quebec.
Salutary Neglect: The wars with France left the British government deep in debt. As Chancellor of the Exchequer, Robert Walpole
had devised methods to keep the British treasury solvent, including
creating a “Sinking Fund” through which to pay down (but not pay off)
the debt from Queen Anne’s War. The debt was one of the causes of the South Sea Bubble in 1720. The debt and the economic collapse forced Walpole, now Prime Minister,
to find ways to cut spending. In 1723, he created the policy called
Salutary Neglect. It relaxed enforcement of the Navigation Acts and
allowed the colonial economy to run along essentially
unregulated. But the loosening of oversight had broader effects
on the colonies than just economic. The colonies grew closer together
and developed a sense of identity different from England. Salutary Neglect ended with the French and Indian War
when, Britain started controlling the colonies by imposing new economic
regulations, taxes, and restrictions on movement. During the brief time
of unsupervised growth, the colonies experienced a Great Awakening and
the Enlightenment. When it was abruptly ended, it caused a groundswell
of opposition that would eventually grow into an American Independence
movement.
Developments During the Era of Salutary Neglect:
Great Awakening:
Many elements combined to create the revival movement of the mid-1700s
known as the Great Awakening. Beginning in New England, many people
believed that churches no longer met their spiritual needs. Many
preachers, meanwhile, were frightened by the lack of piety among the
citizens, especially on the frontier. Religious tensions had occurred
before, in New England particularly, but this time it seemed the masses
were rejecting the “city upon the hill” altogether.
Church membership had never been easy to
obtain. It was important, however, because many of the rights of
citizens derived from church membership. Additionally, much of the
orderliness of Massachusetts society derived from church membership:
those outside the church were also outside the ruling structure of the
colonies. One source of tension was church membership for the
unconverted. In the late 1650s, the question arose as to whether
children of original church members were properly converted to
Puritanism. Second generation church members had been baptized and
admitted to the church on the strength of their fathers’ conversion,
but few confessed their own “calling” to the church. Thus, the question
arose as to whether the children of these unconverted should be
baptized and admitted to the congregation. In 1657, the issue reached a
head and a group of ministers met to see if they could come to some
agreement over the matter. Confirmed in 1662, the agreement was known
as the half-way covenant:
unconverted members could transmit membership to their children, but
the membership only went “halfway;” children would be baptized, but not
take communion. And as adults, they would not be allowed to vote;
halfway members had to pledge to obey the church and to raise their
children as Christians; they also sat separated from full church
members. Slowly over time, the halfway distinctions disappeared. The
blurring of the line troubled conservatives who fretted over the decay
of the church. So what had been an unstable compromise became even less
satisfactory, particularly after some churches started inviting all
congregants to take communion. To regain order, Massachusetts churches
trended away from congregational authority and began to centralize, a
reform that proved a move in the wrong direction.
In other colonies, churches were even less
capable of meeting citizens’ spiritual needs. In Virginia, the state
church was the Church of England, which tried to establish a religious
orthodoxy among the settlers. Missionaries of the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts
(SPG) had been sent to the colonies to convert the Indians, but they
soon found that their time would be better spent trying to sustain the
Church of England against the rise of Scots-Irish Presbyterianism. SPG
tactics caused many settlers to oppose them.
In the hyper-religious or supernatural world of colonial America, these
tensions played out in eerie and often destructive ways. The witch
hysteria that overtook Salem and other New England towns, in part, grew
out of conflicts within congregations. Religious tension mingled with
social unrest, natural disasters, and an apparent increase in immoral
behavior to create the “Great Awakening.”
In 1734-1735, Jonathan
Edwards, a Congregationalist minister from Northampton in western Massachusetts, began a rekindling of the American spirit of piety. It
is no mystery why it occurred on the extremities of the colony first. A
Baptist clergyman had once called frontiersmen, “A Gang of frantic
lunatics broke out of Bedlam.” Edwards stirred his audience with
explicit descriptions of the torment of hell-fire and damnation. In
1737, Edwards published his account of the event, Faithful Narrative of the Surprising Work of God.
![]() |
The real catalyst of the Great Awakening, however, was George Whitefield,
a 27 year old Anglican minister from England. In 1739, he arrived in
Philadelphia to stir up piety. By December, he had won renown preaching
to crowds of as many as 6000. He continued his tour of the colonies in
Georgia and then New England. Whitefield was a showman. He performed in
the pulpit--acting out the horrors of damnation and the joy of the
regenerate. Whitefield’s meetings were so popular they often were moved
outside to accommodate the audience. The core of Whitefield’s message
was the idea of “new birth”--the need for a sudden and emotional moment
of conversion and salvation where a sinner would testify his (or more
often her) finding Christ. Imitators of Whitefield popped up all over
the colonies. Itinerant preachers traveled throughout the frontier
regions of the colonies to spread the word. |
The Great Awakening caused tension
between conservatives and revivalists. Presbyterians split into “Old
Side” and “New Side;” Congregationalists became “New Light” or “Old
Light.” Newer sects, such as Baptist and Methodist, made inroads into
the colonial population. Puritanism was decimated. The balance between
reason and faith broke down and piety and the emotional extravagance of
the conversion experience as something beyond reason became eminent.
Jonathan Edwards led this new theology. He took a more intellectual
approach than Whitefield, though. Indeed, he wrote some of the most
eloquent sermons and religious tracts ever composed in America. He
tried to reconcile Calvinism with the Enlightenment. In 1754, he
published what might be his most important work: Of Freedom of the Will, but his best known work is a sermon entitled, “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” (1741).
The upheaval of the Great Awakening brought
different reactions from colony to colony. In Massachusetts, backlash
against the emotionalism of the revival led to the rise of the
rationalist sects, such as Unitarianism. In Virginia, reaction was
slower to come (1760s) but when it did arrive the “New Light” Baptists
and Presbyterians began a consolidated effort to overwhelm the Church
of England.
| He purchased a print shop and the Pennsylvania Gazette. He turned the newspaper into a great success by offering occasionally sensational or even fictional stories for the amusement of readers. He also began publishing Poor Richard's Almanack, an annual journal that amid its accounts of holidays or weather forecasts included witty and wise sayings. Among them were such memorable teachings as: "A penny saved is a penny earned;" "the rotten apple spoils his companion;" "God heals and the doctor takes the fee;" and a series of tutorials to labor: "a used key is always bright;" "never leave that till tomorrow which you can do today;" "the sleeping fox catches no poultry;" and "there will be sleeping enough in the grave." Of particular interest to Franklin were sayings regarding economy and thrift. In 1758, he created the character of Father Abraham to deliver a sermon on frugality and the evils of idleness. The popularity of Father Abraham was astronomical. He became popular not just in the colonies. Father Abraham raised the celebrity of Franklin in England and France, as well. | ![]() |
![]() |
In his mid-forties, he sold his interests in these publications making of himself a wealthy man and began to pursue his true interest: science. Necessity being the mother of invention, Franklin devised numerous very practical inventions, including: the bifocal lens (so that one wouldn't have to keep switching spectacles to read and see at a distance); the Franklin stove (a small fireplace that would generate great heat with minimal fuel--later inventors modified the stove and greatly improved on Franklin's idea); swim fins (small rounded fins that fit onto one's hands like gloves); and the odometer (to measure distance and speed up the public mails) among other things. His greatest scientific achievement, however, related to the studies of electricity and weather. His most famous experiment involved the discovery that lightning was really electrified air. From his research he developed many theories that helped future scientists advance our knowledge and control of electricity. He also created the lightning rod, a vitally important invention which dramatically reduced the danger of fires started by lightning hitting homes, barns, and other buildings. His Experiments and Observations on Electricity was published in 1751. |
George
Washington: The list of George Washington's accomplishments
is too long and varied to include in total on this site. Here are a few
of the most important:
Born at Wakefield Plantation,
in Westmoreland County, Virginia, he grew up in relative privilege. Although
not intellectually the equal of many of his contemporaries, such as Franklin,
Adams, or Jefferson, he took advantage of opportunities, both professional
and personal, and his physical attributes to become "the Father of his
Country."
He first came to prominence
as a colonel in the militia during the French and Indian War. In 1754,
Washington was ordered to establish
the English claim to the source of the Ohio River in western Pennsylvania
(land also claimed by France). The competing presence there sparked a skirmish
between Washington's troops and the French and their Indian allies. Within a year, the conflict would develop into an all-out
war.
Although the war would
continue until the English won in 1763, Washington resigned his commission
in early 1759 and returned to Virginia and married a well-to-do widow,
Martha Custis. For the next fifteen years, he ran his plantation, Mount
Vernon, south of Alexandria and served in the House of Burgesses. As the
American Independence Movement heated up, Washington served as a delegate
to the First and Second Continental Congresses (see below) and once the
shooting started, he served as Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army.
Using so-called Fabian tactics (knowing that discretion is the better part
of valor and that when you are weaker than your opponent it is oftentimes
better to run away so that you can live to fight another day) and a little
help from his friends (particularly the French--Lafayette and Rochambeau),
he took a rag-tag bunch and defeated the mightiest military force of the
day. In 1783, with victory in hand, he once again resigned his commission
and returned to the life of a planter at Mount Vernon.
As the new government
faced crisis in the mid-1780s, Washington returned to service, presiding
over the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787. Upon the constitution's
ratification, he was elected first President of the United States. His
administration established numerous precedents and has been almost universally
described as a great success--arguably given the difficulty of the task
no one was better suited and no one could have done a better job. The times
were not without turmoil, however. Despite his call for nonpartisanship,
he oversaw the time when political parties were created and participated
(even if passively) in their creation.
More importantly, however, he oversaw
the creation of Washington, D.C. as the national capital and secured the
stability of the nation against threats both foreign and domestic (see:
Whiskey Rebellion and Jay's Treaty). Worn out from the politics, he chose
not to serve a third term and in September 1796 he delivered his Farewell
Address to Congress in which he advised his successors of that fact and
others: notably, to be conservative and slow to tinker with the Constitution,
to avoid political partisanship, and to preserve America's independence
by avoiding permanent entangling alliances.
Washington returned
to Mount Vernon and died there in December 1799, the result of the Quinsy
(strep throat) and the doctor's attempted cure (excessive bleeding or leeching).
French and Indian War, (1754-1763):
In 1747, several wealthy Virginians established the Ohio Company. Among the investors were George Washington’s brother and Lieutenant-Governor Robert Dinwiddie. Hoping
to make money in the fur trade and in land speculation, in 1748, the
company received a 200,000 acres grant in western Pennsylvania at the
forks of the Ohio River, near present-day Pittsburgh. The land was also
claimed by France and in 1749, troops went to the region to shore up
France’s claim by building or expanding a series of forts, and
befriending the Indians. In October 1753, now-Governor Dinwiddie sent
an expedition led by Washington to Fort Le Boeuf (near present-day
Erie, PA) to negotiate a French withdrawal. The French refused. On the
trip back to Williamsburg, in January 1754, Washington’s expedition
skirmished with French and Indian forces around Fort Duquesne.
Returning to the region in May 1754, Major Washington and his forty
troops engaged the French and Indians in the Battle of Jumonville Glen.
The English won and Washington set out to build Fort Necessity.
In July, French attacked the fort and forced Washington's withdrawal
(July 4th, 1754). The skirmishes developed into the last French-English
global war for empire, the Seven Years’ War.
In 1754, Ben Franklin devised the Albany Plan of Union
to enable the colonies to protect themselves. Delegates met in Albany,
New York, to form an alliance with the Iroquois against the French and
their Huron allies; and potentially to create a governing council for
all the colonies. It was not an independence movement; it intended only
to bring the colonies closer together. Some colonies thought it was a
good idea, but a majority did not want to give up any power over their
own affairs to another layer of government.

The war, in America, was inconsistent. In 1755, General Edward Braddock
led British troops to the area and was ambushed by Indians and
Frenchmen in Indian costumes. Outflanked and surprised, the English
were defeated and Braddock was killed. George Washington again the
retreat.
Little of significance on the battle-front
occurred between Braddock’s death and the fall of the French fort
Louisbourg in 1758. What was important was William Pitt’s
ascension to Prime Minister. Pitt reorganized the British government
and allocated resources (military and financial) necessary to win the
war and establish Britain’s imperial dominance once and for all.
Pitt’s policies turned the tide of war. In upstate New York, the Ohio
and Niagara regions, and on the Mississippi, British troops made
significant gains, including building Fort Pitt at the forks of the
Ohio. Then in September 1759 came the death knell for the French in
North America. General James Wolfe led a British force against the Marquis de Montcalm at the Citadel of Quebec. Both commanders were killed in the British victory in the Battle of the Plains of Abraham.
The Treaty of Paris (1763)
ended the French and Indian War. In it, France gave up all claims to
North America, ceding land east of the Mississippi to Britain and west
of it to Spain. The land between the Appalachians and the Mississippi
posed an opportunity and a problem for Britain. Colonials wanted to
flood the territory and the Transylvania Company
(whose investors included George Washington and Ben Franklin) was
created in Virginia to speculate in lands in Kentucky. But each new
incursion by colonials resulted in war with the Indians. So King George III banned colonists from entering the region. The Proclamation of 1763
banned all settlement west of the continental divide in the
Appalachians. Colonists were outraged. Many, including North Carolinian
trailblazer Daniel Boone, simply ignored it and went anyway. The Proclamation brought a formal end to the era of Salutary Neglect.
![]() Death of James Wolfe at Quebec, 1759 |
![]() Battle Sites of the French and Indian War
|
|
|
|
As Salutary Neglect ended, a
series of new taxes and enforcement procedures further demonstrated
that the British were going to change the rules on the colonies and
further alienated colonists.
| “The
colonists will have an equitable right . . . to be represented in
Parliament, or to have some new subordinate legislature among
themselves. It would be best if they had both. . . . Besides the equity
of an American representation in Parliament, a thousand advantages
would result. . . . It would be the most effectual means of giving
those of both countries a thorough knowledge of each others interests.” James Otis |
| “It
is inseparably essential to the freedom of the people, and the
undoubted rights of Englishmen, that no taxes should be imposed on
them, but with their own consent, given personally, or by their
representatives.” Patrick Henry |
|
“Declaration of Rights and Grievances”
That
the inhabitants of the English Colonies in North America, by the
immutable laws of nature, the principles of the English constitution,
and the several charters or compacts, have the following Rights:1. That they are entitled to life, liberty, and property. 2. That [those] who first settled these colonies, were . . . entitled to all the rights, liberties, and immunities of free and natural born subjects within the realm of England. 3. That by such emigration they by no means forfeited, surrendered, or lost any of those rights. * * *
5.
That the respective colonies are entitled to the common law of England,
and to the great and inestimable privilege of being tried by their
peers.6. That they are entitled to the benefit of such of the English statutes [that] they have, by experience, respectively found to be applicable to their several local and other circumstances. 7. That these, his majesty's colonies, are likewise entitled to all the immunities and privileges granted and confirmed to them by royal charters, or secured by their several codes of provincial laws. 8. That they have a right peaceably to assemble, consider of their grievances, and petition the King. 9. That the keeping a Standing army in these colonies, in times of peace, without the consent of the legislature of that colony in which such army is kept, is against law. 10. It is indispensably necessary to good government . . . that the constituent branches of the legislature be independent of each other; that, therefore, the exercise of legislative power in several colonies, by a council appointed . . . by the crown is unconstitutional. . . and destructive to the freedom of American legislation. The key point, beyond basic legal rights, in the Declaration is Part 4. wherein the Congress discusses representation.
4.
That the foundation of English liberty, and of all free government, is
a right in the people to participate in their legislative council: and
as the English colonists are not represented, and from their local and
other circumstances, cannot properly be represented in the British
parliament, they are entitled to a free and exclusive power of
legislation in their several provincial legislatures, where their right
of representation can alone be preserved, in all cases of taxation and
internal polity, subject only to the negative of their sovereign, in
such manner as has been heretofore used and accustomed. But, from the
necessity of the case, and a regard to the mutual interest of both
countries, we cheerfully consent to the operation of such acts of the
British parliament, as are bona fide restrained to the regulation of
our external commerce, for the purpose of securing the commercial
advantages of the whole empire to the mother country, and the
commercial benefits of its respective members excluding every idea of
taxation, internal or external, for raising a revenue on the subjects
in America without their consent.
The Declaration warned of the actions colonies intended to take to make Parliament back down to “restore us to that state in which both countries found happiness and prosperity, we have for the present only resolved to pursue the following peaceable measures: 1. To enter into a non-importation, non-consumption, and non-exportation agreement or association. 2. To prepare an address to the people of Great Britain, and a memorial to the inhabitants of British America, and 3. To prepare a loyal address to his Majesty, agreeable to resolutions already entered into.” |
| Parliament: What used to be the pride of the Americans? Franklin: “To indulge in the fashions and manufactures of Great Britain.“ Parliament: “What is now their pride?“ Franklin: “To wear their old clothes over again till they can make new ones.” Many colonies enacted “Non-importation Agreements,” establishing boycotts of all British goods. One result of the boycotts was that colonials could no longer buy British cloth or clothing. They began wearing homespun instead. This gave the revolutionary era a drab fashion, as homespun was a coarser fabric than British textiles and lacking in the variety of dye colors. |
![]() |
| “Parliament has a right to bind the colonies in all cases whatsoever.” Declaratory Act, 1766 |
Boston Massacre:
Tensions continued, but Townshend’s
untimely death and replacement by Frederick, Lord North calmed neither
side. The issue festered until the winter of 1770. On the cold, moonlit
evening of March 5th, a group of young men began taunting a sentry with
snowballs at the Customs House in Boston. Soon the snowballs turned to
ice, rocks, and coal lumps. The group became a mob as several hundred
converged on the Customs House. Eight soldiers reinforced the lone
sentry when he called and as the mob bashed sticks together and threw
whatever was at hand, a soldier fired and then the platoon fired into
the crowd. By the time the dust cleared, five colonials lay dead,
including an African American dockworker named Crispus Attucks, often considered the first casualty of the Revolution.
Samuel Adams called the killings “bloody butchery” and asked Paul Revere to create an illustration of the event.
![]() |
|
“Unhappy Boston! See thy sons deplore
Thy hallowed walks besmear’d with guiltless gore. While faithless Preston and his savage bands, With murderous rancor stretch their bloody hands; Like fierce barbarians grinning o’er their prey, Approve the carnage and enjoy the day. If scalding drops, from rage, from anguish wrung, If speechless sorrows lab’ring for a tongue, Or if a weeping world can aught appease |
The plaintiff ghosts of victims such as these;
The patriot’s copious tears for each are shed, A glorious tribute which enbalms the dead. But now, Fate summons to that awful goal, Where justice strips the murderer from his soul Should venal C____ts, the scandal of the land, Snatch the relentless villain from her hand, Keen execrations on this plate enscrib’d Shall reach a judge who never can be bribed.” |
The Boston
Massacre scared both sides. Samuels Adams and Joseph Warren continued
to organize resistance, reviving the Committee of Correspondence. And
in Virginia, Patrick Henry and others, including Thomas Jefferson,
created a Committee of Correspondence in response to the Gaspee Affair,
when New Englanders destroyed a British revenue ship that had tried to
stop smuggling in Rhode Island. But as a matter, tensions and
conditions eased between 1770 and 1773. Lord North assisted in easing
the conflict by repealing the Townshend Duties on all goods, except
tea. He left the tax on tea, it is said, “as a mark of the supremacy of
Parliament, and an efficient declaration of their right to govern the
colonies.”
Boston Tea Party:
The taxes on tea caused John Hancock to lead a boycott on tea from China imported by the British East India Company. The boycott caused significant debt for the company, which then lobbied Parliament for assistance. The Tea Act of 1773
eliminated the import duty on the company’s tea and enabled the company
to sell its tea at a lower price than Hancock’s (and others’) smuggled
tea. Hancock and his protégé, Samuel Adams, were
particularly upset by the new arrangement.
On December 16th, 1773, the issue came to a
head. Three ships carrying a new cargo of tea were to land at Griffin’s
Wharf. That night, Adams’ Sons of Liberty met at the South Meeting
House to organize their protest. Some dressed up as Mohawk Indians,
others as women, and they sneaked through the dark down Congress Street
to the wharf. They boarded the ships and tossed 45 tons of tea, valued
at £10,000 into the harbor. The tea washed up on the shores of
Boston Harbor for weeks afterward.
The British response was quick and severe. In
March, Parliament enacted a series of laws, known collectively as the Coercive Acts
because they meant to coerce better behavior from Massachusetts, or as
the Intolerable Acts because the colonials found they could not
tolerate them.
1. Boston Port Act: closed the port of Boston to all traffic and trade.
2. Act for the Impartial
Administration of Justice: moved all trials to Admiralty Courts in
Halifax.
3. Massachusetts Government Act:
the Royal Governor appoints the colonial council and law enforcement
officers.
4. Quartering Act of 1774,
which expanded the requirement to provide room and board for British
soldiers, including in private homes, if necessary.



Battle of Lexington and Concord:
On April 14th, 1775, Gage received
orders to arrest Hancock and Samuel Adams, who were in hiding In
Lexington. Gage was also to confiscate weapons in a rebel supply depot
in Concord. Four days later, 700 British Marines assembled in Boston
Common before setting out to Lexington. The question arose of which
route the British intended to take out of town: across the Charles
River or along the Boston spit; the route would help determine which
way Hancock and Adams would escape.
The Boston Committee of Correspondence had spies throughout town, including the sexton of the North Church. Committee member Paul Revere
set up a code by which the Robert Newman could inform him of the route.
As Revere waited in a boat on the river, Newman was to hang lanterns in
the church bell tower: “one if by land, two if by sea.” The two
lanterns in the tower told Revere that the British were crossing the
river. He rowed to Charlestown where a horse awaited him and then he
rode through the countryside declaring, “the Regulars (or Redcoats) are
coming.” Two others, William Dawes and Samuel Prescott,
were doing the same thing. Between Lexington and Concord, all three
were captured and detained by British roadblock, but Prescott escaped
and continued the warning. Dawes also escaped. Revere, however, had his
horse confiscated and had to walk back to Lexington. He arrived just in
time to see the battle.
On April 19th, the redcoats met the Minutemen on Lexington Green,
someone fired a shot and war began. British troops routed the militia,
but suffered over 250 casualties on their return to Boston. 93
colonials died in the battles.
With shots finally fired, all of New
England prepared for war. Two expeditions, one from the Green Mountain
part of New Hampshire (Vermont) led by Ethan Allen, and one from Massachusetts led by Benedict Arnold planned to attack a British outpost on Lake Champlain, Fort Ticonderoga.
The two forces met in May 1775 and with the help of local spies the
colonials overpowered the British garrison. Winning the fort itself was
less significant than taking what was in it: 174 artillery pieces and a
huge cache of ammunition. The large guns, by mid-June would be
transported back to Boston. In a daring nighttime artillery assault,
George Washington's Continental Army moved the guns to Dorchester
Heights, south of
the city, thus holding the highest land in the sector and putting
important British installations in range.
The other colonial regions were less united in their response to Lexington and Concord. In New York, patriots organized the militia, while loyalists
sent a letter to Gage asking him to suspend further attacks until
orders came from England. New Jersey was split between patriots and
Tories, led by Governor William Franklin
(illegitimate son of Ben Franklin). Quaker Pennsylvania divided between
pacifists and fighters, while the rest of the colony divided into
patriots, led by Franklin, and loyalists, led by John Dickinson.
In the Chesapeake, Maryland opposed revolution, while Virginia (and
especially Patrick Henry) supported it. A month before Lexington, Henry
urged the House of Burgesses to organize a militia, giving his
oft-quoted speech, “Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be
purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God!
I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty
or give me death!”
Loyalism was stronger in the Lower South,
particularly in the back-country among the Scots-Irish who distrusted
the Low Country planters. But a strong patriot contingent also existed
in the Carolinas, as well as Georgia. On May 20th, Mecklenburg County issued four resolutions and declared its independence: “We
do hereby declare ourselves a free and independent people; are, and of
right ought to be a sovereign and self-governing association, under the
control of no power, other than that of our God and . . . Congress: To
the maintenance of which Independence we solemnly pledge to each other
our mutual co-operation, our Lives, our Fortunes, and our most Sacred
Honor.”
Second Continental Congress:Meeting,
beginning in May 1775, after the Battles of Lexington and Concord, it
was the first that included delegates from all of the colonies. The
delegates were split. There was strong sentiment to avoid further
conflict, but preparedness was important. The Congress named George Washington as Commander-in-Chief of the proposed Continental Army.
| Battle of Bunker Hill (June 17, 1775): First major battle of the war; 2,200 British redcoats fought to take the heights north of Boston. Overdressed on a blistering hot day and with the colonists holding the better position on Breed’s Hill, wave after wave of British soldiers attacked and was mowed down. The British eventually won the battle but it was a Pyrhhic victory as they suffered 1,054 casualties. |
After Bunker Hill, John Dickenson tried once again to restore peace. He wrote the “Olive Branch Petition,” sent to England on July 8th, 1775. Thomas Jefferson wrote a companion piece that explained the action of forming colonial militias: Declaration
of the Causes and Necessity of Taking Up Arms (July 6, 1775)
Ironically, the Olive Branch Petition reduced
the colonies’ ability to negotiate because if the king rejected it,
then there would be little for the colonies to do but either give in or
become independent. News of Bunker Hill and Fort Ticonderoga arrived in
England just before the petition. News of Benedict Arnold’s assault on
St. John, New Brunswick, and intrigues to get Quebec to join the
movement arrived shortly after. Many in Britain also wanted
conciliation, but the vote to accept the petition lost 86 to 33. In
August, King George III called the colonials rebels and rejected the
petition. Instead, he turned to Europe for troops. Prussia, Russia, and
Holland rejected his entreaty, but several German principalities and
city-states complied, most notably the state of Hesse, which supplied
nearly 13,000 Hessian mercenaries.
Common Sense:
| “I
HAVE never met with a man, either in England or America, who hath not
confessed his opinion, that a separation between the countries would
take place one time or other: And there is no instance in which we have
shown less judgment, than in endeavoring to describe, what we call, the
ripeness or fitness of the continent for independence.” Tom Paine |
Pamphlet
written by radical Quaker, Tom Paine, and published in January 1776; it
argued that it made no sense for the colonies to stay part of England.
Its fiery language and clear reasoning helped convince the large segment
of undecided to join the independence movement.
| To
CONCLUDE, . . . many strong and striking reasons may be given to show
that nothing can settle our affairs so expeditiously as an open and
determined declaration for independence. Some of which are, It is the custom of Nations, when any two are at war, for some other powers, not engaged in the quarrel, to step in as mediators, and bring about the preliminaries of a peace; But while America calls herself the subject of Great Britain, no power, however well disposed she may be, can offer her mediation. Wherefore, in our present state we may quarrel on for ever. While we profess ourselves the subjects of Britain, we must, in the eyes of foreign nations, be considered as Rebels. [Last]ly. — Were a manifesto to be published, and despatched to foreign Courts, setting forth the miseries we have endured, and the peaceful methods which we have ineffectually used for redress; declaring at the same time that not being able longer to live happily or safely under the cruel disposition of the British Court, . . . at the same time, assuring all such Courts of our peaceable disposition towards them, and of our desire of entering into trade with them; such a memorial would produce more good effects to this Continent than if a ship were freighted with petitions to Britain. Under our present denomination of British subjects, we can neither be received nor heard abroad; the custom of all Courts is against us, and will be so, until by an independence we take rank with other nations. These proceedings may at first seem strange and difficult, but like all other steps which we have already passed over, will in a little time become familiar and agreeable; and until an independence is declared, the Continent will feel itself like a man who continues putting off some unpleasant business from day to day, yet knows it must be done, hates to set about it, wishes it over, and is continually haunted with the thoughts of its necessity. |
![]() |
![]() |
John Adams was the Boston lawyer who led Independence movement at Second Continental Congress. Although short in stature, he had a strong mind, a huge ego, and an ability to drive his colleagues crazy with sheer force of character. He was ambassador to Great Britain during the Confederation era, was first vice-president and second President of the United States. Although a Federalist, he alienated party leader Alexander Hamilton. His inept handling of international affairs, meanwhile, made him a target of great hostility and derision from republican political opponents. Losing the election of 1800 to Jefferson, Adams left Washington professing his disdain for the new president.
Thomas Jefferson was the main author of the Declaration of Independence, he was an inventor, writer, and musician. During the War of Independence, he was Governor of Virginia. He was ambassador to France during the Confederation era, the first Secretary of State, second vice-president, and third President of the United States. Fiercely political, he clashed with Hamilton and led the Democratic-Republican Party. He opposed a strong central government, but a critical compromise in the 1800 election and his Louisiana Purchase continued the expansion of the national government’s power. Jefferson's second term was marked by continued conflict with England and France. To avoid war, Jefferson signed the disastrous Embargo Act. He left office in 1809, relieved to be free of the burdenof the presidency. The political rivals patched up their differences after Jefferson left office. They corresponded over the ensuing years. On July 4, 1826, Adams died; his last words being, “Jefferson survives.” But Jefferson had died at Montecello earlier that day.
Virginia Resolves: Passed by the House of Burgesses and delivered to Philadelphia by Richard Henry Lee, they declare Virginia’s support for independence from England; the resolves gave the needed boost to the Adams wing of the Second Continental Congress and virtually ensured independence
The
Declaration of Independence:Founding document of the United
States signed on July 4, 1776. It was written by committee (Ben Franklin,
John Adams, Roger Sherman, Robert Livingston) with most of the work done
by Thomas Jefferson: the document is in four parts:
1. a preamble, offering an introduction
as to the purpose of the document
2. declaration of natural rights, based
on Locke's “social contract:” life, liberty, pursuit of happiness
3. presentation of the list of particulars
or complaints against King George III: the “history of repeated injuries
. . . ”
4. statement of intent, i.e. the actual
declaration of that the colonies are now a independent, sovereign country:
“these United Colonies are, and of right ought to be, free and independent
States . . .”
The War of Independence
Battle of Brooklyn Heights (August 1776): Among the first defeats for Washington’s Continental Army, it occurred on Long Island and enabled the British to occupy New York City and make it their headquarters for the rest of the war. More importantly, it demonstrated Washington’s choice of military tactics – Fabian tactics – meeting the enemy on the field, but making sure of an escape route; or, in other words, running away to live and fight another day.
Battle of Trenton (December 1776): Washington’s daring winter crossing of the Delaware River surprised the Hessians (German mercenaries fighting for Britain) and led to the Continental Army’s first victory and a morale boost. It demonstrated that the U.S. would be most successful employing hit-and-run, guerrilla tactics against the much stronger British force.
Battle of Saratoga, NY,
(October 1777): Defeat of British under Gen. John “Gentleman Johnny”
Burgoyne and the turning point of the war: it led to an American alliance
with France and eventually Spain

Washington winters at Valley Forge (December 1777 – June 1778): Perhaps the darkest and hardest time of the war for the Continental Army under Washington. Ill-equipped, demoralized, hungry, and on the brink of defeat, the troops received proper training from Baron von Steuben, a German who came to America to help the cause of Independence. The troops were whipped into shape and, with Ben Franklin’s establishing the alliance with France, ready to face the British in the spring.
Battle of King’s Mountain (October 1780): American victory in the Carolinas that showed the effectiveness of the U.S. troops under Gen. Nathaniel Greene (known as Washington’s “ablest general”). After it Greene was named Southern Commander. His troops chased the retreating British under Lord Cornwallis to Guilford Court House (Greensboro) where another Pyrrhic victory for the British marked the beginning of the end British control in the U.S.
Battle of Yorktown (August – October 1781): Just miles from the site of Jamestown, the U.S., under the command of George Washington and with considerable help from the French, defeated the British after a long siege and Cornwallis surrendered, ending the war.
Surrender of Cornwallis at Yorktown by John Trumbull
Peace of Paris (September 1783): Treaty ending the War of Independence, negotiated by Ben Franklin, John Jay, and Henry Laurens: with it the U.S. gained control of all the land east of the Mississippi River, north of Florida, and south of British Canada; U.S. gained fishing rights in the Grand Banks. In November, the British evacuated New York City. A month later, General Washington resigned his commission as Commander of Continental Army, showing that a civilian government would run the U.S.
The Confederation Era, 1783-1789
Articles
of Confederation:
With independence, it became necessary for each state to reconstitute
its government. Given their unhappiness with the monarchical
experience, the states universally chose a republican form and a written constitution. Debates at the Massachusetts Constitutional Convention in 1779-80 offer an eloquent statement of the goals and beliefs:
“The body politic is formed by a voluntary
association of individuals; it is a social compact, by which the whole
people covenants with each citizen, and each with the whole people that
all shall be governed by certain laws for the common good.”
Each state had an elected governor and a senate, and most wrote bills
of rights to provide basic protections to the people. The rights
included: freedom of speech, the right to petition, trial by jury , and
freedom from self-incrimination. In 1776, John Dickinson drafted a
national constitution, called the Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union. It was adopted by the Continental Congress in 1777, but ratification by the states took until 1781. It created a “diplomatic congress of autonomous states.” Ratification of the Articles was delayed by the debate over control of western lands.
The Confederation government did have some important achievements.
Northwest Ordinance, 1787:
With
the Land Ordinance of 1785, this law represents one area of success of
the Confederation era. It organized the Old Northwest territory into states:
Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, and eastern Minnesota; it
forbids slavery in these new territories.
Manumission: Independence
and talk of freedom during the Revolutionary Era created an
inconsistency for national leaders who were also slave-owners. The
contradiction caused several masters to suggest that they would free
(manumit) their slaves. And some, such as George Washington, actually
did it. Meanwhile many northern states confronted with the
inconsistency (and not being as economically dependent on slave labor)
abolished slavery in the 1780s.
|
States
|
Mass.
|
N.H.
|
N.Y.
|
Conn.
|
R.I.
|
Penn.
|
N.J.
|
Ver.
|
|
European Settlement
|
1620
|
1623
|
1624
|
1633
|
1636
|
1638
|
1620
|
1666
|
|
First record of Slavery
|
1629
|
1645
|
1626
|
1639
|
1652
|
1639
|
1626
|
1760
|
|
Official End of Slavery
|
1783
|
1783
|
1799
|
1784
|
1784
|
1780
|
1804
|
1777
|
|
Actual end of Slavery
|
1783
|
1845
|
1827
|
1848
|
1842
|
1845
|
1865
|
1777
|
|
Percent black 1790
|
1.4%
|
0.6%
|
7.6%
|
2.3%
|
6.3%
|
2.4%
|
7.7%
|
0.3%
|
|
Percent black 1860
|
0.8%
|
0.2%
|
1.3%
|
1.9%
|
2.3%
|
2%
|
3.8%
|
0.2%
|
The Confederation government also successfully created government departments
to carry out its most essential duties: Foreign Affairs; War; and
Finance, as well as the Post Office. Foreign Affairs was headed by New
Yorkers Robert Livingston and then John Jay, but was ineffectual. The War Department was headed by Henry Knox;
it was lucky we were at peace because without money for troops we would
not have been able to put up much of a fight. Finance was headed by Robert Morris,
the Philadelphia merchant who had almost single-handedly financed the
Revolution. Morris created the Bank of North America, a
privately-owned, part government-financed institution to hold federal
deposits (if there were any) and to facilitate borrowing (which there
was a lot of). An otherwise decentralized banking system, vested local
interests, and general distrust of centralized authority stymied
Morris’ attempts to organize the national government’s economic
affairs.In frustration, Morris and others, including Alexander Hamilton threatened a coup d’etat,
if the states did not give more power to the national government. When
Hamilton solicited George Washington’s support for the coup, however,
the Newburgh Conspiracy was ended. Washington thought the idea too risky and entirely too dishonorable.
| Forgive me, Gentlemen, but I have grown blind as well as gray in service of my country -- Gen. George Washington to the Newburgh Conspirators
|
Despite these
successes, the Articles were severely flawed. The federal government
was too weak to take care of disruptions and disputes in or among the
states.
|
Weaknesses
|
Effect
|
|
Congress had no power to levy or collect taxes |
The national government is dependent upon the states and is always short of money |
|
Congress had no power to regulate interstate or foreign trade |
Economic quarrels broke out among the states. It was difficult to arrange a coherent foreign trade policy |
|
Congress had no power to enforce its laws |
The national government is dependent upon the states to enforce laws |
|
Approval of nine states was needed to enact laws |
It was difficult to enact laws, especially given the absence of quorum |
|
Amendments to the Articles required unanimous vote |
Amending the Articles was impossible given Rhode Island’s non-participation |
|
The national government had no executive branch |
There was no way to coordinate the work of the government
|
|
There was no national judiciary or court system |
The national government had no way of settling disputes among the states |
Given
the obvious flaws in the Articles, several leaders from Maryland and
Virginia met at Mount Vernon to discuss how to fix them, as well as to
speculate on some potential business ventures that might bring more
development to the nation. They suggested a convention of the states to
meet in Annapolis, Maryland (U.S. capital) at which delegates would
discuss reform. The meeting was held in September 1786, but so few
states sent delegates that no debate occurred. They decided to try
again in Philadelphia in the new year. The failure of the Annapolis
Convention further demonstrates the weakness of the federal government.
Shays’ Rebellion:
Over the winter of 1786-87, farmers in western Massachusetts found
themselves unable to pay their mortgages because of a poor harvest and
a tax increase. Armed (and usually drunk), the farmers rose up in
protest. Led by Daniel Shays, they took over courts to block judgments
against their farms. Some began a march on Boston and rumors abounded
that they were on a rampage and heading to Annapolis to overthrow the
government. The government was thrown into a panic. The inability of
the federal government to stop the uprising showed the weakness of the
Articles and caused a national emergency.
“Miracle at Philadelphia”:
Constitutional
Convention of 1787—after years of ineffective government, the country’s
leaders met in Philadelphia to create a new plan of government. George
Washington presided and Benjamin Franklin gave his authority to the project.
Thomas Jefferson (Ambassador to France) and John Adams (Ambassador to England)
were not there. In the summer heat, with the windows nailed shut and the
doors locked because of armed protesters marching outside, the delegates
debated, disagreed, compromised, and drafted the Constitution
of the United States, the oldest written constitution still in use.
| Alexander Hamilton (1755-1804): In the early days of the Revolutionary War, he distinguished himself as a brave soldier when, in August 1775, he led a militia in seizing cannons from the English fort at Battery Park. He became aide-de-camp to George Washington in 1777. A lawyer and a formidable mind, he was one of New York’s delegates at the constitutional convention. He led the Federalist faction, calling for a strong central government. President Washington named him his first Secretary of the Treasury Department. Hamilton's economic policies, notably assumption of the state debts and creating a national bank, helped to establish a foundation on which the new national economy could grow. A rival and ideological opponent of Jefferson, he helped cause the formation of political parties in the 1790s. He left government upon Jefferson's election in 1800 and was killed in a duel with Aaron Burr in 1804. | ![]() |
| James Madison (1751-1836): A wee man with a weak physical constitution, he was one of the most brilliant thinkers and writers of his age. He became known as the “Father of the Constitution”: he led the Virginia delegation at the convention; kept notes on the proceedings of the convention; devised the Virginia Plan (see below); and, with Hamilton, led the Federalist faction. To satisfy opponents of the Constitution, he wrote the Bill of Rights (1791) and led its ratification Congress. He split with Hamilton to join Jefferson’s Republican faction (mid-1790s), revising his earlier calls for a strong central government (see Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions below). He became the fourth President of the United States. (1809-1817). |
Representation: The major disagreement among the delegates at Philadelphia was over how the states would be represented in the new Congress. Less populous states wanted equal representation—to have equal number of representatives, as in the U.S. Senate (2 per state); the more populous states wanted proportional representation—a.k.a. representation by population–states with more people have more representatives than states with fewer people, as in U.S. House
Separation of Powers: Built upon Montesquieu’s ideas of (divided sovereignty), this system divides power and authority among three branches of government so that government will not become too powerful.
Checks and Balances: Coinciding with the separation of powers, this system gives each branch of government a check (control) on the power of the other branches and thereby balances power among the three: in theory, no one branch is more powerful than the others. A primary example of the system is the presidential veto wherein a President can reject a bill passed by Congress and the Congress can override the veto with a super majority (60%)
Virginia Plan: Conceived by Madison and offered by Edmund Randolph, it aimed to overhaul of the Articles and create a stronger central government: a bicameral legislature with representation based on population; a strong executive and judiciary selected by the legislature—also known as the “Large States Plan.”
New Jersey Plan: a.k.a. the “Small States Plan,” offered by William Paterson of New Jersey. It proposed tweaking Articles: keeping the unicameral legislature, but giving the national government the power to impose and collect taxes and to regulate trade; and creating a national judiciary. It would keep the relationship of the confederation, maintaining the sovereignty of the individual states.
Connecticut Compromise: offered by Roger Sherman of Connecticut, it split the difference on the question of how representation would be determined. Following the Virginia Plan (the Large States Plan), it called for a bicameral legislature with the lower house having proportional representation (by population), but the upper chamber would have equal representation (two Senators selected by each state).
Three-fifths Compromise: The most obnoxious part of the Constitution, this counted slaves as three-fifths of a person for representation and taxing purposes. It was forced on the convention because the South wanted to count slaves as a whole person so that it would get more representation in Congress; but it did not want slaves counted at all for taxes; non-slaveholding states opposed both positions and forced compromise.
Slave Trade Compromise: Opponents of slavery wanted to abolish the foreign slave trade (importation of slaves from outside the U.S.). Slave states opposed the plan and threatened to leave the convention. Framers reached a compromise whereby the slave trade could not be abolished for twenty years (or until 1808) and the federal government could not tax southern exports.
Commerce Clause: Art. I, Sec. 8, Pt. 3: Coincides with the agreement on taxing southern exports (export tariff): a federal government would have the power to regulate interstate and foreign trade (fixing a critical problem with the Articles) but it could not tax exports from any state.
Legislative Branch: Established in Article I of the Constitution, it is the law-making branch of government composed of the House of Representatives and the Senate
Executive Branch: Established in Article II of the Constitution, it is the law-enforcing branch of government composed of the President, Vice President, Cabinet, and agencies (i.e. bureaucracy).
Judicial Branch: Established
in Article III of the Constitution, it is the law-interpreting branch of
government composed of the Supreme Court, Courts of Appeals, and District
Courts.

Ratify: “to accept” –each state formed a convention of delegates to debate and to decide on whether to accept the new constitution
The Federalist Papers: One of the most important documents in U.S. history, this series of essays written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay explains and defends the Constitution from the perspective of the Federalist faction (the supporters of a stronger central government). The essays were published in New York newspapers and were written to convince New Yorkers to ratify the Constitution.
Anti-Federalists: Unorganized group opposing the Constitution, they wrote essays answering the Federalists in which they explained the dangers of placing too much power in a federal government and defended the basic structure of the Articles of Confederation. The Anti-Federalists demanded that the Constitution be amended to include a written Bill of Rights to protect the people and the states from an aggressive federal government. They included Virginia’s Patrick Henry and George Mason; Samuel Adams and Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts; and John Dickinson of Pennsylvania.
Bill
of Rights: The first ten amendments to the Constitution, drafted
by James Madison and written to satisfy concerns of Anti-Federalists. It
describes the rights retained by the people and the states under the new
more centralized system. Some of the rights include: freedom of speech,
assembly, religion, and the press; right to a speedy trial before a jury
of peers; right to bear arms; right against self-incrimination and double
jeopardy.